Brazil rejects $25bn Mariana disaster settlement offer from Vale, BHP

Mining Technology· Ivan Bandura on Unsplash.
GlobalData
2 min read
2
In this article:

Brazil's federal government and the state of Espirito Santo have reportedly turned down a $25.03bn settlement proposal from mining giants Vale and BHP for the 2015 Mariana tailings dam collapse.

The offer, which included $9.2bn already disbursed, was deemed insufficient and laden with "inadmissible conditions" by the office of Brazil's solicitor general, reported Reuters.

The dam collapse at the Samarco iron ore mine, a joint venture between Vale and BHP, unleashed a deluge of mud and mining waste, claiming 19 lives, displacing hundreds, and causing extensive environmental damage to the Doce River in Minas Gerais state.

Despite the proposal's increase in funds allocated to federal and state governments, it suggested a significant reduction in the companies' previously agreed obligations.

Notably, the plan implied a drastic cutback in the removal of mining tailings from the Doce River, with the government suggesting it bordered on a scenario of no removal at all.

Silveira was quoted by in Bloomberg News as saying in an interview in Rome: “I cannot fail to express my outrage at how brazen it is for Vale and BHP to present a settlement proposal for the humanitarian tragedy of Mariana that’s less adequate than the previous one. We’ll reject it.”

While the federal government and Espirito Santo have expressed firm opposition, the Minas Gerais government has adopted a different stance.

Minas Gerais Secretary for Planning and Management Luisa Barreto was cited by Reuters as saying that the state intends to continue negotiations over the current proposal.

In response to the rejection, BHP reaffirmed its commitment to fair reparation and compensation measures while Vale emphasised its dedication to reaching a fair and comprehensive repair agreement.

Samarco also communicated its openness to dialogue and its responsibility towards concluding the agreement discussions.

"Brazil rejects $25bn Mariana disaster settlement offer from Vale, BHP" was originally created and published by Mining Technology, a GlobalData owned brand.


 


The information on this site has been included in good faith for general informational purposes only. It is not intended to amount to advice on which you should rely, and we give no representation, warranty or guarantee, whether express or implied as to its accuracy or completeness. You must obtain professional or specialist advice before taking, or refraining from, any action on the basis of the content on our site.

Advertisement

Recommended Stories

  • The coming Social Security fight could be 1983 all over again

    To figure out how Social Security's insolvency debate may play out in the years ahead, it helps to consider what transpired in 1983.

  • Does the SAB 121 Vote Mean Anything for Future Crypto Legislation?

    The U.S. Senate joined the House of Representatives in voting to repeal a controversial U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) accounting rule that imposed burdensome capital requirements on crypto custodians. Unfortunately however, the legislative measure is now heading to the desk of President Joseph Biden, who has vowed to veto it in a show of solidarity with the SEC. Although a number of high profile Democrats, including New York Sen. Chuck Schumer, voted in favor of overturning the bulletin, the Senate’s 60 to 38 vote on Thursday failed to cross the threshold to override a presidential veto.

  • Crypto Industry Rallies Behind House Bill as It Heads Toward Final Vote

    The U.S. House of Representatives is on the verge of a vote that will represent the closest the cryptocurrency industry has ever been toward finally winning regulation in the U.S., and the sector's associations and top businesses are encouraging House leaders to support the effort.

  • Vindicated by Supreme Court, CFPB director says bureau will add staff, consider new rules on banks

    Since its creation roughly 14 years ago, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has faced lawsuits and political and legal challenges to the idea of whether the Federal Government's aggressive consumer financial watchdog agency should be allowed exist at all. The opinion reversed a lower court's ruling and drew praise from consumer advocates, as well as some in the banking industry, who argued that upending 14 years of the bureau's work would cause chaos in the financial system. Now cleared of any legal ambiguity, CFPB Director Rohit Chopra told reporters Friday that the bureau plans to hire additional investigators and has already filed legal motions on roughly a dozen cases pending against companies accused of wrongdoing that have been held up due to the Supreme Court case.

  • Joe Manchin Joins With Republican Lawmakers in Push to Overturn DOL Fiduciary Rule

    Dozens of members of Congress are backing resolutions of disapproval that would derail a policy they say will limit access to retirement advice.

  • US, TikTok seek fast-track schedule, ruling by Dec. 6 on potential ban

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) -The U.S. Justice Department and TikTok on Friday asked a U.S. appeals court to set a fast-track schedule to consider the legal challenges to a new law requiring China-based ByteDance to divest TikTok's U.S. assets by Jan. 19 or face a ban. TikTok, ByteDance and a group of TikTok content creators joined with the Justice Department in asking the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia to rule by Dec. 6 to be able to seek review from the Supreme Court if needed before the U.S. deadline. On Tuesday, a group of TikTok creators filed suit to block the law that could ban the app used by 170 million Americans, saying it has had "a profound effect on American life."

  • TikTok Parent Seeks to Fast-Track Suit Over US Divest-or-Ban Law

    (Bloomberg) -- China-based ByteDance Ltd. asked an appeals court to speed up its lawsuit challenging a US law that would force it to sell the TikTok video-sharing app or face a ban.Most Read from BloombergGantz Says He’ll Quit Unless Netanyahu Moves to New War PlanA 25-Year-Old BofA Trader Dies Suddenly at Industry OutingChina-Bound Oil Tanker Hit by Houthi Missile in Red Sea, US SaysUS Company Becomes World’s Most Valuable Solar Firm After Chinese Rivals SlipZyn Shortage? Nicotine Pouches Out o

  • The Unfortunate Truth About Receiving the Maximum $4,873 Social Security Benefit

    A monthly check for $4,873 might sound great, but it might not be everything it's cracked up to be.

  • ‘The stress is killing me’: I’m 73 and crumbling under $200,000 in debt — and I have no savings. Can anyone help me?

    “I’m current with all my bills but barely make minimum payments.”

  • Prediction: This Will Be Nvidia's Next Big Announcement

    Nvidia's dominance in the artificial intelligence chip market has helped the stock to soar.